UniCredit is ending remote work. Being in the same room sets the stage. It does not produce the music.
This week, one of Europe's largest banks told its most senior leaders that remote working was over. UniCredit applied the change to CEO Andrea Orcel's direct reports immediately, and according to the unions, remote work is now an exception that must be agreed in advance. From January, the rule extends across the workforce.
The unions are not happy. They rejected what they called a unilateral decision, which went against their hopes of extending remote working to branch employees, as other banking groups have done. The bank's reason is simple. In-person collaboration, it says, supports "knowledge sharing, professional development and effective teamwork." It adds that it remains committed to flexible working.
Since the pandemic, remote work has moved from emergency measure to expectation, and for many people to entitlement. So the question in every boardroom watching Milan this week is not really about UniCredit. It is this: if you bring everyone back into the room, do you get a team?
I'll start with an admission
Readers may expect a leadership writer to defend flexibility. On the central point, though, Orcel is right.
An orchestra does not rehearse remotely, and not because of tradition. Ensemble playing depends on things that do not survive a screen: the breath before an entrance, the glance between the concertmaster and the principal cellist, the tiny adjustment one section makes because it heard another lean forward. In The Maestro CEO I wrote that blend is chemistry, and chemistry cannot be bought by the seat. It is cultivated, and that happens in shared space.
Organisations behave the same way. When everyone works remotely, people keep collaborating with the colleagues they already know, and the informal links across teams fade. Junior people lose the most, because a large part of their learning comes from overhearing: how a senior colleague handles a difficult client call, how a decision really gets made, what nobody writes down. Professional development, one of UniCredit's stated aims, is the part that suffers most when the room empties.
So the room matters. But that is where the easy part of the argument ends.
A full stage is not a performance
I have heard orchestras where every chair was filled and nobody was listening. Technically present, musically absent. Each player was excellent alone, and together they sounded like a hundred people waiting for the session to end.
That is the risk UniCredit now faces. An office mandate produces attendance. It does not produce teamwork. Teamwork needs three things no policy can order: people listening to each other, trust that disagreement is safe, and leadership spread through the sections rather than concentrated at the front.
There is also a structural problem specific to a pan-European bank. Its teams span Milan, Munich, Vienna and beyond. Ordering people back to their desks does not put Milan and Munich in the same hall. Much of the knowledge-sharing gap in a group like this is between countries, and it will still run through video calls, now made from an office instead of a kitchen.
What a Maestro would do differently
Start with the principals, then make them play differently. UniCredit got the sequence right. Leading with the CEO's direct reports is what a conductor does: shape the reading with the section leaders before the full orchestra arrives. But returning to the office only matters if the principals change how they behave once they are there. A senior leader who comes back and spends the day behind a closed door teaches the organisation that being present means being seen, not being available. The principals have to be on the floor, teaching and reachable.
Decide what in-person time is for. Rehearsal time is precious, so a conductor never wastes it on what players can practise at home. Leaders should be just as clear about what the office is for: solving problems together, mentoring, the decisions that need everyone in the room. Teams should share the same in-office days, so that sections are actually together rather than scattered across a half-empty floor.
Listen to the section that is objecting. The unions' response is not noise. It is information. It shows a trust gap, and it shows that branch staff, who never had the flexibility headquarters enjoyed, feel the policy was written for others. A conductor who imposes a tempo without hearing the orchestra gets compliance, not music. Consultation is not weakness. It is rehearsal.
Define the exceptions now. According to the unions, the company has not made clear which exceptions will apply. Ambiguity breeds suspicion, and suspicion is what destroys teamwork. The best players always have other offers. If they cannot see how the rules will apply to them, many will not wait to find out.
Measure blend, not attendance. Badge data counts bodies. It cannot tell you whether juniors are getting more feedback, whether decisions across teams are moving faster, or whether knowledge is flowing between sections that used to ignore each other. If the goal is teamwork, measure teamwork.
So, will it be enough?
No. Ending remote work removes an obstacle to teamwork. It does not create teamwork.
The research on hybrid working is clear that flexibility retains talent at little or no cost to performance. The research on proximity is equally clear that being together speeds up learning, especially for those early in their careers. Both are true. A good leader holds both and designs for the trade-off rather than pretending one side does not exist.
UniCredit has secured the hall. The harder work, getting a hundred talented people to listen to each other once they are inside it, has not started yet, and no memo can do it.
The hall is necessary. The music is still the conductor's job.
This piece draws on the fifth movement of The Maestro CEO: Orchestra. If you lead a team that is physically together but not truly playing together, I would be grateful if you shared it.
— José